top of page
Search

1847 WRECK OF A DAVIESS COUNTY FLATBOAT

dchistory
1 minute ago
5 min read

            In 1825 James Graham (1771-1838) bought 121 acres in Daviess County, Indiana and moved his family from Kentucky.  After he died, his son, Thomas Bolden Graham, Sr. (1806-1889), took over management of the family farm and purchased more land.  In 1846 the yellow corn harvest on the large Graham farm was bountiful and Thomas wanted to sell the surplus.  To get the best price, he needed to transport his corn to New Orleans, Louisiana.

            In the early 19th century, the only way for farmers in the upper Midwest to convey their agricultural products—corn, wheat, potatoes, flour, hay, whiskey, chickens, cows, and pigs—to New Orleans was on a flatboat going down the Mississippi River.  The Mississippi flatboat traffic grew from 598 arrivals in New Orleans in 1814 to 2,792 arrivals in 1847.

In 1847 Thomas Graham hired James Carnahan—a 38 year old Daviess County carpenter who had previously built 22 flatboats—to construct three rectangular, flat-bottomed “Mississippi broad horns” to transport his corn to New Orleans.  The boats were built with Daviess County timber and were 76 feet long, 20 feet and 4 inches wide, and 7 feet high from the floor to the roof.

Each boat needed a five man crew: a pilot, two bow hands, and two oarsmen. Each craft was equipped with four side oars (“sweeps”) and a steering oar at the stern.  The oarsmen pulling on the 30 to 50 foot long “sweeps” could provide some propulsion, but the flatboats were designed primarily to float downstream with the river current.  The craft traveled three to five miles per hour depending on the depth of the river.

Lithograph of a 19th century Mississippi broad horn flatboat
Lithograph of a 19th century Mississippi broad horn flatboat

Graham employed three pilots and 12 crew members—all from Daviess County—to take his flatboats to New Orleans.  Abel T. Morgan, a 42 year old farmer and experienced flatboat pilot, was in command and piloted the lead flatboat.  James Carnahan was pilot of the second boat, named Broad Horn No. 4, and Richard Bratton piloted the third craft.  On March 16, 1847 the three boats left Daviess County from the Maysville landing on the West Fork of the White River.  Each carried 3,400 bushels of yellow corn on the ear. 

 The plan was to descend the White River to the Wabash River, then down the Ohio River, and into the Mississippi River to New Orleans.  The 1,300 mile journey was expected to take three to four weeks.  At New Orleans, the corn was to be sold and the flatboats dismantled and sold for lumber.  Graham thought he might get as much as 90 cents per bushel for the corn.  The pilots and crews would return to Daviess County by steamship, stagecoach, and horseback.

The first two weeks of the trip went well and without incident. On the evening of March 30, 1847, the three Graham boats approached Memphis, Tennessee on the Mississippi River where the river is a mile and a quarter wide.  They landed on the Tennessee side to get supplies, 300 yards above the U.S. Navy shipyard at Memphis.   Near the shipyard, anchored in the Mississippi River about a quarter of mile from shore, was the USS Allegheny, a 1,000 ton, iron-hulled, U.S. Navy frigate.    

                                 A model of the USS Allegheny 
                                 A model of the USS Allegheny 

The next morning the Graham boats put out into the river.   As they drew near the Allegheny, they saw it was “loose anchored”—only fastened at the bow—causing the 185 foot long frigate in the strong current to swing back and forth in the middle of the river.  Three other flatboats ahead of the Graham fleet tried to pass the Allegheny on the right.  All three were struck and sunk by the pivoting warship.

  Captain Morgan in the lead Graham flatboat decided it was safer to pass the Allegheny on the left and successfully did so.  The second Graham boat, Broad Horn No. 4, followed on the left, but was hit in the bow by the swinging frigate, severely damaged, and sank to its roof.  James Carnahan and his crew, Wilson Carnahan, John G. Carnahan, Harrison Freeland, and Richard S. Richey, were not injured and managed to beach the wrecked flatboat.  The 3,400 bushels of corn on board were destroyed.

The cargo on Broad Horn No.4 was not insured.  Graham filed a petition with the U.S. Congress seeking damages from the U.S. Navy.  On March 9, 1848, the U.S. House of Representatives Committee of Claims found in his favor and recommended he recover $2,701 in damages (the equivalent of $111,172 in 2026 dollars).  The U.S. Senate Committee of Claims disagreed and recommended that Graham not receive any compensation.

Graham filed a claim with the U.S. Court of Claims.  His attorneys argued the Allegheny, swinging in the middle of the Mississippi River, had unlawfully obstructed navigation on the river. In 1849 the deposition of William W. Hunter, Commander of the Allegheny, was taken.  He acknowledged the frigate was fastened with a single anchor, was swinging 45 degrees in the strong current, which resulted in collisions with flatboats trying to pass her.   He testified, however, the Allegheny was “secured in a seamanlike and proper manner” and there was “ample room” for descending flatboats to safely pass the frigate “with proper care.”

In 1859 the depositions of Abel T. Morgan, James Carnahan, and the crew of Broad Horn No. 4 were taken at the courthouse in Washington, Indiana.  They testified there were “no ardent spirits” on board the Broad Horn No. 4 from the time it left Maysville.  They said Broad Horn No. 4 could have passed safely by the Allegheny if the frigate was anchored at both the bow and stern and not swinging in the current. 

On April 8, 1861, the judgment of the U.S. Court of Claims was issued finding that Graham was not entitled to any damages from the U.S. government.  Judge Edward G. Loring wrote the opinion and Judge George P. Scarbrough concurred. They found there was “no fault or negligence” by the U.S. Navy, the Allegheny was properly anchored, and “there was room enough for [Broad Horn No.4] to pass on either side” of the Allegheny.

Although Thomas Graham lost the case and received no compensation, he did gain a small moral victory.   Judge James Hughes of the U.S. Court of Claims issued a dissenting opinion to Judge Loring’s decision.  Judge Hughes said anchoring the Allegheny in the Mississippi River’s channel “was an obstruction to the free navigation of the river.” He wrote: “I think [Graham] is entitled to recover $2,192.15.”


Sources: 

1.      In 2026 Victor Shelton donated to the Daviess County Museum a flash drive with copies of documents, deposition testimony, affidavits and other evidence submitted in Thomas B. Graham v. The United States.  Thank you Mr. Shelton for finding, copying, and sharing these important documents about the maritime history of Daviess County.  These records may be viewed at the Museum’s online site, daviesscounty.pastperfectonline.com, Object Number 2026.0075.

2.      Flatboat, Wikipedia.

3.      Mississippi River Flatboats – The Semis of Yesterday, Maritime Museum of Louisiana.

4.      The Story of Graham Farms (1961). This book may be viewed at the Daviess County Museum’s online site, daviesscounty.pastperfectonline.com, Object Number 2018.FIC.5019.

5.      USS Allegheny (1847), Wikipedia.

 

This article was compiled by Bruce Smith.

 
 

Follow

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube

Contact

(812) 257-0301

Address

212 E Main St PO Box 2341 Washington IN United States 47501

©2017 by Daviess County Historical Society Museum. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page